Tuesday, October 28, 2008

best pick / worst pick

here is the best pick and worst pick of the first 10 rounds of the draft. this is based on 1 persons opinion, only compared within that round, trying not to count injured players and only through the first 8 weeks of the season.

Round 1
Best - Marion Barber
Worst - lots of stinkers and not counting Brady, I'll go Grant

Round 2
Best - Drew Brees (Portis is a close 2nd)
Worst - a few bad ones here too, but Larry Johnson stands out

Round 3
Best - Andre Johnson has been a beast this year
Worst - palmer has been hurt, so I'll say Holt or James (at least McFadden is a potential keeper)

Round 4
Best - Antonio Gates
Worst - Chad Johnson hasnt been hurt, so he gets it (but Laurence Maroney only went on the IR last week so...)

Round 5
Best - Roddy Roddy Piper White (did anyone expect this - bonus 4 times already)
Worst - Derek Anderson (but only because Braylon was a keeper and not really a pick)

Round 6
Best - Santana Moss (4th in WR points)
Worst - Javon Walker

Round 7
Best - Matt Forte (keeper potential)
Worst - San Diego D/ST (1st DEF off the board)

Round 8
Best - Kurt Warner (2nd in QB points)
Worst - SEA D/ST (allowed 25 points 4 times this year)

Round 9
Best - Phillip Rivers (in the same round as Schaub and Bulger)
Worst - Jabar Gaffney (Really?)

Round 10
Best - Aaron Rogers
Worst - Jon Kitna (kinda an injury but really was benched)

1 comment:

Tim said...

Round 2 was a gold mine, with Fitzgerald, Portis, Brees, and Bush.

Round 4 is the anti-round 2, with a ton of stinkers (Roy Williams, Colston--although he's been injured, Johnson, Holmes, and Winslow). I could make an argument that Welker has been as advertised; he hasn't been under double-digits since week one. He is probably at the top of a relatively week round.

Round 6 is another crappy round, largely due to injury, with Reggie Brown, Marvin Harrison, Selvin Young, Bobby Engram, and Joey Galloway.

DeSean Jackson in round 8 isn't a bad pick, especially considering keeper potential. Jay Cutler is also a decent pick.